Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

Does he need a Friend or does he want a Girlfriend?

User Profile: selfdisciplinedFig2292
selfdisciplinedFig2292 October 9th, 2018

Im 21 and in college. Almost a year ago this guy that I graduated high school with randomly messaged me on Instagram completely out of nowhere. It was kinda weird because I dont think Ive ever actually talked to him before. I knew who he was, but I kinda thought it was a mistake. All he said was like Hey hows it going? so I just replied with a really short, quick answer. But then he replied again and he continued to drag out the conversation.

So then I started to think maybe something was wrong and so I was just upfront and I said really nicely like, Hey I dont mind that youre messaging me, but we dont really know each other so like are you OK? Is anything up? and he seemed really appreciative that I was asking and he admitted that basically my speculation was right and he really has just been feeling lonely. He dropped out of college after his first year and ever since hes gone back home and just been working small jobs and trying to figure out what he wants. And I totally get that.

I felt lots of sympathy right away because Ive been there before where I didnt know what I wanted. And also not long before this all happened I had gone through periods of just feeling totally lonely.

So I can imagine how hes feeling with all his friends off at school while hes back home.

So I started making friendly conversation with him and I decided to invite him to hang out with a couple of my close friends and me over winter break and I think he had fun. But since then he keeps asking if we can hang out together but just the two of us and Im starting to get a feeling of caution now.

For the record like Im in a super happy and healthy relationship with my boyfriend of 2 years and I made it clear to him that I have a boyfriend just by mentioning it casually a couple times.

I totally want to believe that guys and girls can just be friends, but that mentality and my giving guys the benefit of the doubt has gotten me into accidental dates and bad situations like that. So because of my experience before where my friendliness is taken the wrong way, I cant help but feel a little hesitant and like keeping my guard up just in case.

I dont want him getting the wrong idea and I hope I dont seem conceited because Im thinking this way. But at the same time, Im worried because what if he is truly just wanting a friend and Im just awful for avoiding this person who is legitimately lonely and needs help.

Do you think he is lonely and I should try to reach out to him in person or should I just kinda distance myself because you think that maybe he does have some kind of ulterior motive?

Thank you!

3
User Profile: Larsila
Larsila October 9th, 2018

It seems to me like you don't mind being friends with him and helping him but are afraid you'll end up in a situation you've been in before as you described. What I would do is just tell him about this. Tell him you wouldn't mind and like to hang out with him one on one but that you're a bit worried because you've been in awkward situations before and about your boyfriend. You could also talk about this with your boyfriend so if this would turn out in another awkward date-like situation he knows you didn't see it that way.
Of course you don't have to straight up take my advice on this. Do what you feel most comfortable with but I feel like just being open about things and telling others about your worries helps avoiding misunderstandings.

Good luck!

User Profile: GhostBunnywhite
GhostBunnywhite November 19th, 2018

@selfdisciplinedFig2292 from IG usually those guy are lonely or need to fuck after seing your profile pic..
Many friends told me that.. ( male friends )

User Profile: PerpetuallyKekastrophic
PerpetuallyKekastrophic November 19th, 2018

Males and females have been proven time and time again to not work out very well as "just friends", so i'd suggest letting him down as gently as possible and then staying away for both his sake and your sake, mostly because being "friend zoned" can be the most heart breaking and depressing thing that can happen to someone of the male sex, and because males and females need different things out of a relationship, this includes friendships as well, the two sexes simply have too many different expectations, there are cases where males and females CAN be friends, it's not impossible, but it is important to ask if there are any other motives first and foremost, if needs be, be blunt and just get the important questions over with.

Here is a scientific study:
https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/the-attraction-doctor/201304/can-men-and-women-be-just-friends