Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

The "Crazy" Question

User Profile: astuteScorpius
astuteScorpius September 7th, 2015

Usually this wouldn't bother me and I hear it so often, but I happened to be late on my medication tonight so this particular instance finally set something off in my head.

I work as a phlebotomist/lab assistant at a major hospital. I go around and collect blood orders from patients on all the inpatient units. It's not unusual for me to come in to draw on patients who are doing the screening questions asked at the beginning of every admission.

One of them, perhaps a life-saving one, is deemed as the "strange" or "crazy" question.

'Have you had any recent thoughts of harming yourself or others?'

I've heard so many admitting nurses preface this question with "I know this is weird/crazy/strange but we have to ask everyone who comes in.." For someone like myself with Major Depressive Disorder who has struggled with it their whole life and whose lab coat hides 6 prominent self-harm scars, it irks me any time I hear nurses refer to it as the 'crazy' question. Why not just preface it with 'we have to ask everyone who comes in' and leave it at that? Why continue to pursue the negative stigma attached to mental illness, self-harm, and suicide when you're supposed to be a professional who helps people regardless of what ailment they come into the hospital with?

Someone who has a history of self-harming or who is afraid of their Depression now has a reason to say no. Saying 'no' could be putting them in harm's way. Teaching people that even nursing professionals think they're "crazy" or "broken" or "weird" because they have these torturous thoughts.

It just really happened to bother me tonight.

3
User Profile: HarryC
HarryC September 7th, 2015

Hi there @astuteScorpius, I think you have a really good point here. I don't think it is right to label such a question as the "crazy" question. It is a very forward question to ask and may shock people when they have to answer the question because it is a random question to ask. Maybe the nurses call it that, to try and make the patient feel less at ease. But I agree with you 100%

2 replies
User Profile: astuteScorpius
astuteScorpius OP September 7th, 2015

I understand their side of it as well because it is a very forward question and may shock some people, I just feel it could be phrased better is all.

Like I said it doesn't normally get to me, tonight has just been a weird night and I wanted to get it off my chest.

1 reply
User Profile: HarryC
HarryC September 7th, 2015

It could be phrased in a better way. I hope that getting it off your chest made you feel better. Have a grate day :)

load more
load more