Who should I pick?

I have known two boys for the last 3 years. I became friends with boy 1 first but eventually ended up getting closer to boy 2. I still talk to boy 1 but boy 2 gets very jealous when I talk to boy 1. Recently, boy 2 has been very distant and it’s hurting me. I’m wondering if I have made the wrong choice in letting my friendship with boy 1 not grow because of boy 2.