Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

Trying to understand: avoidant attachment, mixed signals, or something else?

User Profile: NotMyFlipFlops
NotMyFlipFlops December 11th, 2025

I’m looking for an outside perspective on a recent breakup with someone I’ve known for 20+ years — we’ll call her K. We’ve always had a strong bond, and when things finally turned romantic, it felt real and mutual.

The part I’m stuck on is how fast things shifted.

The week before the breakup:

There was a small situation after a night where she’d been drinking. Nothing major, just a few things I didn’t like, so I took a day to myself. She responded with, “Take all the time you need. Love you.” She’d never said that to me before, so it felt like real vulnerability and reassurance.

The following week:

We didn’t see each other because her kid needed extra attention(school issues), but she stayed in touch more than usual. She was initiating sweet morning messages — again, not typical for her. It felt like we were turning a corner.

Then the weekend came:

Her kid went to his dad’s and I was excited to finally spend time together, but she got sick. I’d been wondering whether she actually had enough time or space in her life for a relationship, so (stupidly, in hindsight) I basically ended things for her. Not from anger — more from fear and confusion.

I went by to grab my stuff and asked if she had any thoughts. She said she wasn’t going to talk me out of anything, and maybe I was right that she didn’t have time. The second she said it, I regretted ending it. It felt like she just folded inward.

Three days later:

She officially broke it off with a long text basically saying there's nothing wrong with me, nothing I did, she just needs to focus on work, her kid, herself— but then invited me over for dinner, acted totally normal, had me stay the night, cuddled me, everything. The next morning she was cold again, and since then… pretty much silence.

When I finally texted, “Are we even friends anymore?” she said, “Of course we’re friends!”

But her behavior doesn’t match that at all. She’s stayed friends with exes who treated her way worse, so the fact that she isn’t talking to me makes me wonder if it’s because she still has feelings and doesn’t know how to be around me… or if I’m overthinking everything.

The pattern I’ve seen in her:

Pulls close right before things get deeper

Retreats fast when vulnerability rises

Shuts down communication when overwhelmed

Seems to struggle to reconcile what she wants with what her life demands

My questions for the community:

Does this sound like avoidant attachment behavior?

Has anyone seen this “pull close → retreat → pretend normal → disappear” pattern before?

How do you tell the difference between someone losing interest vs. someone getting triggered by closeness?

If you you’ve been avoidant yourself, does any of this track emotionally?

I care about her a lot, so I’m not trying to diagnose or blame. I’m just trying to understand the dynamic and whether what I experienced lines up with avoidant tendencies or something else.

5
User Profile: Amanda84
Amanda84 December 11th, 2025

@NotMyFlipFlops

I'm sorry it has ended for you both.

Even if it were true that she struggled with attachment.

You have be mindful of your own needs.

And limitations.

You cannot change anyone who doesn't want to be changed.

Your feelings matter too 

It's important to set boundaries and protect yourself.

It's not helpful to either of you, for one person to be blowing hot and cold 💖

i-love-you-love-you.gif

1 reply
User Profile: NotMyFlipFlops
NotMyFlipFlops OP December 13th, 2025

Thank you very much.

load more
User Profile: dukeofdearham
dukeofdearham December 13th, 2025

@NotMyFlipFlops,

in my opinion, there is way too much emphasis nowadays on what kind of behavior someone might show and next put a label on it. We tend to overanalyse.

Having said that, I fully understand you try to understand. Which doesn't mean her behavior is excusable. 

I recognize the pattern you describe. Been in a similar situation with my ex wife. Reaching out, closing down, her saying over and over again she wants to be good friends, even best friends, but not putting any effort in it.

She might truly deeply love you but, for whatever reason, doesn't know how, and/or being afraid to be vulnerable and show her true self. 

Her reaching out and withdrawing again wore me out and I decided to leave things for what they were. That was tough, the love on but sides still runs deep. After she opted for divorce, she once said (via a relationship therapist we had at the time, apparently she couldn't say it in my face) that i was the love of her life (was her 3rd marriage).

You can be the most fantastic partner she ever met, but if she can't be the most fantastic partner to herself then it's a road to nowhere.

You made a decision and it might have been your intuition that made that decision. If so, stick with it. You can't change her, only she can.

2 replies
User Profile: NotMyFlipFlops
NotMyFlipFlops OP December 14th, 2025

Thank you so much for this...your insight has brought a lot of clarity and resolve for me.

User Profile: NotMyFlipFlops
NotMyFlipFlops OP December 14th, 2025

Your situation mirrors mine so closely. It was really helpful to hear your perspective. Also I'm sorry it worked out that way for you both.

load more