Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

What would you do?

User Profile: zeetee17
zeetee17 April 1st, 2023

If someone offered you a pill and said "You will lose you memory of bad things that happened to you, you will forget about relationships and people that hurt you, and you will get to start a new life somewhere else without those memories" would you take that pill?

290
User Profile: ThomasX
ThomasX April 8th, 2023

@zeetee17

I wouldn't. It's pointless trying to use drugs to forget about something that has happened in the past. The past is the past, it's gone, and you have grown from the experience, and that growth is what is important. Keeping the memory is what is important, because you know that you will not let yourself get hurt again, so NO, don't take the pill

1 reply
User Profile: AJneon
AJneon May 26th, 2023

@ThomasX

My thoughts exactly

load more
User Profile: zeetee17
zeetee17 OP April 12th, 2023

these have been really interesting answers. thanks for all the responses. I think i would take the pill if it would give me back who I was before the heartache, but a lot of you made a good point of losing the lesson and being drawn into the same situation because I lost the memory and the wisdom

1 reply
User Profile: horsefacer
horsefacer April 19th, 2023

@zeetee17

do you have a pill where you keep the lesson but lose the pain?
Ill take that one please!

load more
April 12th, 2023

@zeetee17 wow, what an interesting question.

On one hand, if I am ready to take that pill, why don't I just let go of the negative feelings and bad memories induced by toxic people in the past and start afresh?

On the second hand, the experience only made me smarter. So, if I take the pill, I will lose the pain but some of my wisdom too. (Sounds a lot like alcohol)

If I take it once, it doesn't guarantee protection from future hurt. To overcome that, I will only need more pills.

And then it turns into a cycle? And if so, where does the cycle end?

I think I will give it a try without the pill. I will take my experiences, remember the pain and set stronger boundaries so that I can protect myself. (and maybe keep the pill as a last resort?)

What would you do?

2 replies
User Profile: Hapra
Hapra April 12th, 2023

Nice answer @DonaldDraper

I would learn options to heal in the pain, so that I wouldn't even need to consider taking a pill

User Profile: YourCaringConfidant
YourCaringConfidant April 19th, 2023

@DonaldDraper Wow! Donald, I just gained more respect for you reading your comment. Absolutely beautiful and soooo wise! ♡ Love, Not Cari*

1 reply
April 20th, 2023

@YourCaringConfidant no words, only 🥰

load more
load more
User Profile: blueSouth5323
blueSouth5323 April 12th, 2023

Yes. I always make the same mistakes. It would help if I forgot after every mistake who I was. And a different place sure why not! It's an ouroboros eating its tail infinite loop.

User Profile: IamtheBat
IamtheBat April 12th, 2023

Memories can sometimes be vile things, but sometimes those very bad memories can also lead to some incredibly beautiful moments in the struggle as well. Memories create reasoning, and to deny those memories is to...by default...deny any form of reasoning as well


If all you experience is only one side of the coin, when will you realise that a coin has 2 sides...if you never experience the bad, how will you know what good is even when you feel it?


It's kinda like experiencing darkness, how will you know the difference if you don't turn off the lights

User Profile: etherealnova
etherealnova April 12th, 2023

yes but i know it all could turn out the same. just anything to escape this.

User Profile: AmioYuko11
AmioYuko11 April 12th, 2023

@zeetee17 Please don’t take that pill. It might sound good to you but trust me its a drug.

User Profile: Sphumi08
Sphumi08 April 12th, 2023

@zeetee17

I'd be very tempted honestly but no I wouldn't. All those things have played a part in shaping the person I am today

User Profile: UnderstandingUnicorn1
UnderstandingUnicorn1 April 12th, 2023

@zeetee17

That's an interesting hypothetical question. Personally, I don't think I would take the pill. While bad memories can be painful, they also help shape who we are and allow us to learn and grow from our experiences. Even the painful ones can have valuable lessons and make us stronger in the long run. Additionally, forgetting people who hurt me might mean missing out on important lessons I That's an interesting hypothetical question. Personally, I don't think I would take the pill. While bad memories can be painful, they also help shape who we are and allow us to learn and grow from our experiences. Even the painful ones can have valuable lessons and make us stronger in the long run. Additionally, forgetting people who hurt me might mean missing out on important lessons I needed to learn or relationships I needed to move on from. While the idea of starting fresh somewhere else may sound tempting, ultimately, I think it's important to face our challenges and work through them rather than simply erase them from our minds.

User Profile: solipsists
solipsists April 12th, 2023

@zeetee17

no i wouldn't take this pill