Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

What would you do?

User Profile: zeetee17
zeetee17 April 1st, 2023

If someone offered you a pill and said "You will lose you memory of bad things that happened to you, you will forget about relationships and people that hurt you, and you will get to start a new life somewhere else without those memories" would you take that pill?

290
User Profile: mamamiaisaac
mamamiaisaac April 25th, 2023

@zeetee17 it depends :P

User Profile: Chloebaby18
Chloebaby18 April 25th, 2023

I would but only for certain people I would want that lol

User Profile: slowdecline48
slowdecline48 April 25th, 2023

Probably.

User Profile: helloGrapes3117
helloGrapes3117 April 25th, 2023

@zeetee17

Yes. I'm older and wiser now. I have better coping skills. I would take the pill and see what kind of human being I'd turn out to be. If taking the pill could lead to self-love, I'd call it a miracle.

User Profile: TinyLittleGlia
TinyLittleGlia April 25th, 2023

No...they are what make us who we are today

User Profile: robs824
robs824 April 25th, 2023

@zeetee17

Yes

User Profile: thoughtfulFriend68
thoughtfulFriend68 April 25th, 2023

@zeetee17 definitely!

User Profile: toughTiger6481
toughTiger6481 April 25th, 2023

Countless movies ..... books.... even songs have addressed this.

Do only you forget or is any help, influence or piece of you wiped away from all those you have encountered? each person or situation is a lesson or a blessing and if you wipe it all away perhaps you will need to go through it again to grow.

We tend to dwell on the bad or uncomfortable parts of life .............yet forget or might not even know that in some moments you may have said or done something that helped others in ways that changed them for the better.


1 reply
User Profile: Tanyuuchan
Tanyuuchan April 30th, 2023

@toughTiger6481

Iclaim trash

load more
User Profile: Dondy154
Dondy154 April 25th, 2023

I think it would erase too much. Years ago my mother had shock therapy which is something they do to wipe parts of your memory to get rid of intrusive thoughts and bad thought patterns like ruminating, but it causes brain damage. She said there were chunks of her young adulthood she couldn't get back.

Your idea would be the same as that, only more selective. Only the bad things would go. But there are so many things in the past that hurt and leave scar tissue I think the memories you would have left would be in tatters. Say I have a good memory of my father reading to me - but remembering that now causes me pain because he is gone and it is linked to memories of him suffering? Would I keep that one or not? If I did keep it I would go on hurting. If I didn't keep memories of that type I'd likely remember so little that I'd no longer have the framework to understand anything about my past and what happened in it.

I don't know how bad a thing that would be. But it would certainly turn me into a lost soul, no past, no future, no context. A whole lot of my personality comes from the events in my life: learning to be independent, learning about and trying not to pass on dysfunctional family traits, learning what I want and need out of life. Do I even need that stuff now? I don't know. But I do know that the me who has those memories now wouldn't recognize a me without them. I would have erased most of who I am.

User Profile: Jewels012222
Jewels012222 April 25th, 2023

@zeetee17

Yes, I think I'd take the pill. Most of the things that have hurt me have not taught me a lesson and have not made me stronger... they were simply cruel. I've learned I'm not resilient. They've made me weak and unable to cope with life in a healthy way. I know I'm more compassionate and empathetic and a lot of people feel they can talk to me because I understand their hurts, but my heart is bleeding out... sometimes at a trickle, sometimes at a gush, but always bleeding. A chance at a different life would be nice.

1 reply
User Profile: zeetee17
zeetee17 OP April 25th, 2023

I appreciate your honestly. Not all the bad things in life are worth the lesson it brings. sometimes there is no lesson, sometimes bad things just happen.

load more