Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

Question about mixed pronouns

User Profile: AffyAvo
AffyAvo October 4th, 2023

I have seen what I think of as mixed pronouns and I'm confused what they mean.

I'm hoping some of you can clue me in. I would just ask the individual but so far it's no one I know personally I see doing this. How would I refer to someone who states the following?

he/them or she/them

they/him or they/her

Does the first line mean something different from the 2nd line?


5
User Profile: 7motivation
7motivation October 4th, 2023

@AffyAvo

Regarding your "Question about mixed pronouns" above.


I too have the same questions.

So I asked Google Bard and Bing Chat GPT-4 in chat conversations.

They gave me similar replies like this:

  • A pronoun mix like:
    “he/they” is generally shorthand for
    “use both he/him/his and
    they/them/theirs pronouns”.

  • However, preferences are different for every person
    and the desired balance among different pronouns
    can be different for each person

  • So it’s important to respect each individual’s chosen pronouns
    as it’s a significant aspect of their identity.

  • So if unsure about someone’s pronouns,
    one can ask politely.

  • Also, the singular usage of the word "they" was used in English long ago.

    But later there was push back by some 18th century grammarians.

    But now it is starting to be considered grammatically correct again.

    See Wikipedia article on "Singular They" for a detailed explanation.

User Profile: linvi
linvi October 28th, 2023

@AffyAvo

I'm curious about this too, I've kinda figured it might mean that the person is comfortable with either neutral or gender specified pronouns. Some people prefer ONLY their identified gender pronouns and others only neutral, so I think that either/or might be just stating you can use either?

Just a guess though

1 reply
User Profile: AffyAvo
AffyAvo OP October 30th, 2023

@linvi That makes sense.

load more
User Profile: NaturalEmpath
NaturalEmpath October 29th, 2023

It's always best to ask the individual since these responses can vary by person. The answers are not black and white and are defined solely by the person who is identifying. For some, the answers are not clear cut and they may want to try it on first. They could be questioning their identity and trying out how each pronoun feels for them.

1 reply
User Profile: AffyAvo
AffyAvo OP October 30th, 2023

@NaturalEmpath I definitely agree with asking, but so far I have only see public figures state pronouns like this. It sounds like there is no standard though when it comes to these, so if I see them, a respectful question would likely be welcomed.

load more