Skip to main content Skip to bottom nav

Boyfriend's job

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding July 23rd, 2022

I'm dating a guy who works as a freelance personal trainer right now - he is hardworking, sweet and yes, has a nice body. We click well and I like him. But having grown up in an asian society where lawyers, doctors, engineers, and other white collar stable jobs are seen as more dependable for men, I am a little embarassed to introduce him to my relatives or acquaintances because I know they would judge. This doesn't seem good in the long run but I also don't want to break up right now because I'm happy when I am with him.

My mind is in a loop...What should I do?


(Separately to girls) When it comes to serious boyfriend, would you consider a freelance personal trainer? ... I am curious about other women's perception

16
User Profile: Helgafy
Helgafy July 24th, 2022

@ctyding

Hi - well, when it comes to being in love it should not count what the person is working with as long as he can make enough money for living/later family. What you can share of thoughts and feelings are very important to many.

User Profile: Helgafy
Helgafy July 26th, 2022

@Helgafy

I of course ment what feelings and thoughts the 2 of you can share .....

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding OP July 27th, 2022

@Helgafy Haha yes, I understood you :) Thank you for the straightforward answer!

load more
load more
User Profile: ImpudentIncognito
ImpudentIncognito July 25th, 2022

I’m going to have to be blunt — Who cares what they think about his job?

Are they paying his bills? Are they taking care of him? Is it physically hurting others that he works there? If the answer is no, then his job is nobody’s business.

At least he is working a job he loves AND has the ambition to make it his OWN business, it’s not easy being an entrepreneur.

Also, there are blue collar jobs that — if nobody did them, then our lives would be worse.

Construction workers work hard everyday to build streets and make traffic safer.

Garbage collectors help reduce pollution and keep our parks, streets, neighbourhoods, etc from being flooded by repugnant trash.

Fitness/personal trainers help others live a healthier and less stressful life, they're also motivators.


This is coming from someone who grew up with a “tiger mother” herself and has nosy/uptight family on the maternal side.

My choices were doctor, lawyer, engineer, or any “prestigious “ job. I studied in a specific field of engineering, and…dropped out after 2 years, because I couldn’t afford it and wanted to get away from my dysfunctional family.

I love technology, but I rather do things on my own terms.

I’m also an (aspiring) entrepreneur[though I do have a regular job as well], and have helped my mother with her business.


I have family members who are engineers and lawyers, BUT they’re ALWAYS stressed out, busy, and have little time for other things which makes them miss out time with their own intermediate/nuclear families.


I’m more impressed by someone who works a job they love and are passionate about, than someone who’s a sheep and only doing certain jobs because they’re told to or because they want to have a higher “status”. There are some people though, that are passionate about being a doctor, lawyer, and engineer, and that’s awesome! But the ones doing it to look better or because they're told to…not so cool. The only jobs I don’t like…are the illegal ones or/and the ones that harm people…


When it comes to a serious boyfriend, I only care that he has a job/is working/at LEAST trying to find work and good personality overall with the same morals/principals as me. Not someone who leeches on me for money and not someone who’s selfish[basically, my ex/son’s dad used me for money and comfort…and was pretty selfish].


However, I do also see where you’re coming from… You mentioned that white collared jobs are seen as more dependable. It’s a valid concern/fear that with his job, you might end up having to take on supporting both of you financially, and that can take a toll on someone. That did to me at least, when I was with my ex/son’s dad. I was the breadwinner, and ended up paying for nearly everything without hardly any help, despite him working too. It made me pretty resentful of him. I hardly even got to spend any money on myself either nor take a break.


I would suggest talking to your boyfriend about how you feel and communicate too…the cultural differences to better explain. For example, tell him you’re worried/concerned his job is not dependable[maybe also add that you’re making sure he’s okay/not suffering financially from this.] Explain to him that the reason you brought it up is because in your culture, white collared jobs are seen as dependable. Maybe even mention that it makes your feel safer/more secure as well? Lastly, you can explain too…how your family would reacr, but reassure him that you love him regardless if what they say/think.


If you happen to be a doctor, lawyer, or engineer yourself, I can also see why you may prefer someone in the same field or class. Just someone who understands you and your work better, and someone to relate to. Furthermore, you don't have to worry about feeling unequal in the relationship [ex. If you make much more than him, but pay for everything, it’ll make you resentful].


Overall, if you feel very strongly about the job, then it is OK to break up. Moreover, if you enjoy his company, then you can keep the relationship casual too, and enjoy it for what it is until it fizzles out or you find someone that matches you more.


Anyhow, I do apologize if I came across harsh, I do not mean to offend.

Just offering another perspective, but also know that you’re feelings are valid[sorry for buzz word, I don't know how else to word this].

It’s okay if you feel this is not a long term match for the reasons you listed.

It’s okay that you have certain expectations/standards that you would like from a partner — ultimately, it is your personal preference, and your business only on what you want.

Do what makes @ctyding happy, do what you want to do!

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding OP July 25th, 2022

@ImpudentIncognito


No offence taken at all! In fact, I'm grateful that you shared so much about your own personal experience. Thank you :)


- You can stop reading here if you want. Just thought of sharing more on this topic.-


I did speak to him on my concerns when he decided to leave his IT job to pursue personal training. But he made it too clear that his years at different corporate jobs made him miserable and personal training makes him happy - even if it means waking up super early or working after the usual working hours to adjust to clients' schedule.


Ruin his happiness is the last thing I want to do, and I'm actually secretly envious of him for having a passion and having the courage to pursue that passion leaving his law degree...unlike me who is only passionate about eating, sleeping, watching tv, travelling, and works hard at my market research job for the sake of status and salary upgrade.

That's why I'm honestly envious of you as well. Keep going at it and congratulations for starting your business! :)


To give a little back story, I was actually quite happy and secure with him (or I thought so) because I know if he has the grit to make his personal training job work, he definitely won't starve and leech off me.

But recently I had reconnected with a friend/acquaintance I haven't spoken to in 14 years after congratulating her for her engagement on instagram. Over the video call with her, she showed off about her huge proposal ring and how men spend more when you love more. She mentioned that her friend who received Tiffany ring from her boyfriend for proposal is so 'cute and innocent' because the diamond on the ring so tiny that you can hardly see. At some point, she also shared her life/dating tip that you should only look for guys with certain jobs that is stable and earn well, and there are certain men with jobs you should avoid. Then said "Like seriously, I wouldn't date for example a personal trainer, you know?" - at this point, she still doesn't know who I am dating.

After her speech about women being happier with high earning men, she asked about my dating life and what does my guy do. When listening to her, I found it toxic and wanted to tell her the truth but at the moment the question was thrown at me... I lied. I said he's in IT.


After the call, I started to feel that deep down, his job must still bother me... and if my partner did what I did, I will find it a red flag... I'm a red flag :/

I'm still not sure why I lied. I think I didn't want to 'lose' to her or be looked down on by someone who was flashing off her sugar-daddy fiance.

However, I also started to recall being bothered that he doesn't have "weekends" to hang out with me because he's training clients. When I meet him in between clients, he smells of dried up sweat from training with client. He also rarely dresses up now because we date when he has a gap, so we sometimes go to restaurants for dates with me in nice dresses and him in gym shorts and tank tops that show his nipples from the side (i.e. "his uniform" because clients like trainers with good bodies). I like how he makes time for me in that short gap between clients, but sometimes it's embarrassing and frustrating. So it's not just the job title but what it entails that bothers me as well. But, yet, I like him for all the little things he does, say and act, and the cozy times we have just watching movies together late night and stuffing our face with our favorite food and drinks.

You're right. I think I should talk to him again about how I'm feeling...
Do you think I should tell him the incident with the recent acquaintance I spoke to as a context? :/ I feel like I'm doing him wrong in a way by lying about him behind his back.

If you had read till here, thank you again :) I really appreciate your thoughts and opinions. And thank you for telling me that my feelings are valid.

User Profile: ImpudentIncognito
ImpudentIncognito July 27th, 2022

Hi ctyding, no problem at all!


To be honest, I left a high paying job for the same reason…I was getting stressed out everyday, and even ended up getting a strand of grey hair. I worked too much and did overtime too. Was still with my ex at the time, but it felt like I was a single parent taking care of TWO boys instead of one…I was even trying to save up money to propose to him and buy rings for us, I’m glad I never got married to him!


I did these high paying jobs because I was capable of it/skilled in those particular fields, and wanted to give my son [and then-partner-now-ex] a good life… I grew up poor, and didn’t want my son to suffer because of it. So I won’t lie, I did do jobs for the money, didn’t care for the status, as long as my son is happy and healthy. So…I don’t blame you at all for doing market research for a salary upgrade. Also, I don’t really…blame you for going for status based on cultural upbringing. When I was younger, I kinda cared, but mostly to just prove to my dysfunctional family that I CAN make it, and I AM worth hit, because they treated me like dirt. I don’t have anything to prove to them anymore, I’m just enjoying my life. I could just be a random fisherman or work in warehouse, and I’d be okay. Ultimately, I rather own my own business so I don’t have to answer to anyone but myself.


This friend/acquaintance that you haven’t spoken to in 14 years sounds toxic and arrogant to be quite frank. She sounds like she’s just gold digging without adding anything to her relationship…also since it’s on social media, we don’t know what’s going on behind closed doors. It could be a miserable relationship, or she could even be lying. My ex had a friend who’d act like he’s rich by posting pictures of expensive stuff he didn’t own, but was homeless. I think he’d literally just walk in the store, try on some stuff, and act like he bought it, when he didn’t so…yeah. She could be faking it, or she might not have as happy as a life as it seems.


My suggestions would be to distance yourself from her, there’s probably a reason why you didn’t speak to her for 14 years, and maybe it should stay that way for your own health and well-being. Don’t let toxic people in your life bring you down.


You’re NOT a red flag, and you know why? You came here asking for help, you came here wanting to do what’s best/right thing. You wanted to know what to do about these thoughts and how to help your relationship. You recognized that getting with someone for status/money is not cool. So relax, it’s okay! Don’t be hard on yourself. We’re all human, we’re all trying to do what’s best.



I’m also wondering…Do you feel maybe more bothered by the situation due to being unable to spend quality time with your boyfriend?

Furthermore, when you do get to spend time with him, you want to have a regular date and not something super quickly put together?

Maybe you guys could find time, at least once a week or once every two weeks to go out and get dressed for a “formal” date. As for spending regular/informal time together…Are you guys able to spend time whether early in the morning or late in the evening?


I’m seeing someone right now with a difficult schedule…He works REALLY late hours, so we hangout late, because he’ll be asleep in the morning. My shifts are 10hrs and in the middle of the day, so I can pick to be either a morning or night person.

We’re also super casual, as I’m not ready for a boyfriend and to be honest…I don’t think I can have a serious relationship with him later down the road. He has some vices that I don’t[says he’s going to quit, but who knows?], and he’s also extremely extroverted and parties a lot, I don’t. I have a kid, he doesn’t. He’s also a friend of two of my brothers, and I don’t really like the idea of dating my brother’s friends forma reason or two…Anyhow…this guy and I are just hanging out, literally just “cuddle buddies” and nothing past that, but he does treat me as a girlfriend and even gave me pet names so idk, we’ll see how the future goes. But probably not lol. I have to be cautious, since I do have a son and last time my son’s dad nearly killed me, so I’m cautious when dating…



Anyhow, in regards to your question, it wouldn’t hurt to bring up the convo your friend said. Maybe word it as “Hey, I just spoke to an old acquaintance I haven’t heard from for 14 years, shes married [etc etc] and she said [mention what she said about men/jobs/money/love etc here lol]” and maybe gauge him for a reaction? Tell him “I know it’s wrong to judge people based on their jobs, but this has been bothering me, it’s been engrained in me for years based on cultural upbringing and I wish it didn’t bother me.” From there, maybe he can share his perspective, advice, or support towards you.


You got this friend! Communication is key, and if you feel the relationship isn’t going where you’d like, then it’s okay too to break it off too. If you don’t want to break it off, leave it casual until you find someone who fits what you’re looking for or if you want it serious, just keep communicating how you feel and you guys will be able to come up with a solution!


Apologies for any grammar or spelling mistakes, doing this on a mobile device and sometimes spell check doesn't catch it…



load more
User Profile: confusedRaven6140
confusedRaven6140 July 26th, 2022

@ImpudentIncognito

I'm aware that there are cultural differences, but in my opinion... who cares if they judge? If you feel this relationship is right, then what difference does it make. Especially if your boyfriend is someone who works hard and would be willing to change jobs if absolutely necessary.

To answer your other question... I probably would not date a PT... but not so much because of the job as because... I don't think I'd really click with most people who fit that demographic. To explain... being able to talk about my job is actually really important to me in a relationship. Because it's not something I can really talk about to family or most of my friends because they just don't understand what I'm talking about (I'm doing a PhD at the moment). So it's kind of important to me that I be able to talk about it to my partner and feel like he understands. But like, if my boyfriend decided to quit science and become a PT, I would have no issue with it as I'd still be able to have those conversations with him.

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding OP July 27th, 2022

@confusedRaven6140 :( My mind knows as well that nobody is living my life and I shouldn't mind too much about what other people say. But somehow at the back of my mind, I can't help think "well, people judge for a reason, right? What if they are right and I'm being naive about life?"

But I totally understand what you meant and your point on being able to click and converse about day-to-day topics is something I definitely find important as well but I started underappreciating that at some point. Thanks for the reminder!

load more
load more
User Profile: dukeofdearham
dukeofdearham July 26th, 2022

So here's a guy who follows his heart and passion, seems to be good at it and is successful.

Who genuinely seems to put effort in you. And there's you, who seems to be calculating, worried about how your family might react. Whether he is dependable.

No offense but I think he deserves better.

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding OP July 27th, 2022

@dukeofdearham Brutal but straightforward - I like :) Thanks for the reality check !


I totally agree with you and ideally I feel that relationships should be non-calculative, and I was that way in my previous relationships.

But as I'm growing older, I wonder... Isn't everyone calculative in relationships and shouldn't that be important in choosing a long-term partner?

Some men consider settling down with women who are willing to take care of kids at home, women who don't overshadow them in career, women who doesn't act like the leader of the household if she's not the breadwinner, women who are pretty, women who are independent and will not be clingy or burden their wallet .... someone to proudly bring to their parents - I mean these are just examples but some guys may value others things.

And likewise, whether a man is dependable is just another factor a woman considers?

load more
User Profile: reliableWest8997
reliableWest8997 July 26th, 2022

Hey, I hope you do not mind my input also. I was reading this, and I admit I did not read the whole thing but I think I understand the situation. I wouldn't worry about other people's opinions if you are happy with him, but it almost sounds like to me you are biased, and although your family or others are the ones judging this person, it sounds like it's affecting you, and therefore you are not happy with him. I guess it means too much to you to have someone with a corporate job or doctor etc. Maybe this guy is not right for you?

User Profile: reliableWest8997
reliableWest8997 July 26th, 2022

oh sorry, I reread your post in more detail and what you said about the dress part. I had the same issue with someone I was seeing also and I agree with you on that. The guy I was seeing or more like not really interested, he does not dress up at all, he is not a corporate person - I still feel thi should not matter as it does not necessarily define who they are, but unfortunately it sounds like you want something that he can't really provide to you, and it sounds like you are not a right match. Is that right? I just had an argument yesterday with this person I was seeing so I am just looking to relate to other people, I am going through a lot with other matters. In the long run, I feel like this particular man that I was seeing, I felt like I couldn't rely on him, and that he was not trustworthy. It was not just one thing but everything together. I wish you good luck whatever you decide. Maybe your gut feeling is trying to tell you something. We can't force something if it's not meant to be. Of course I would have loved to be at least friendly in the long run but it doesn't seem that will be possible either in my case. Anyway, it's important to know when to move on. I feel life is too precious and doing a disservice to myself and everyone if I cannot be with someone like this and I continue. My situation is a bit different maybe, it was toxic from the beginning and I did not see it.

Anyway, I am sorry for rambling on. It would probably help if I had a journal and wrote about these things. I spend a lot of time alone and it would probably also help if I worked on my other relationships... anyway it's important to love ourselves enough to know when it's time to walk away, and also if you care about the other person

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding OP July 27th, 2022

@reliableWest8997 Hey there! Thanks for relating to me and glad that there is someone else that's also facing similar concerns on this platform.
I was also facing a lot of trust issues with my current boyfriend unlike previous people I have dated (but luckily, situation has been improving for me).


Since you mentioned journal, do you want to 'ramble' on further about the situation you are facing? I am interested to know more about it :)

load more
User Profile: toughTiger6481
toughTiger6481 July 26th, 2022

@ctyding

Honestly what you want from a relationship IMO should never require a specific job title or field.

I can see you want other things and your friend seem very materialistic about the ring etc and making comments on other peoples rings.

I have seen people who did very well financially in different jobs and people in "respected" professions that did not always do well.

if you are basing just on what you can tell your friends and family perhaps you need to only shop in the correct profession section.....

I agree on dates and in situations where you are dressed up if he does not have time to change to different attire then plan for a night/ time he has that free time

User Profile: ctyding
ctyding OP July 27th, 2022

@toughTiger6481

I agree with your observation "I have seen people who did very well financially in different jobs and people in "respected" professions that did not always do well". I noticed the same.

I believe in my boyfriend and his hard work. That's why I don't think I need to listen to friends and family.

But it's also the fear that maybe I'm wrong ... voice of crowd is powerful.

:( Also, he rarely has free time to get dressed but I will speak to him like some people suggested. At least I can ask him to stop wearing torn shoes and shirt... I got him new shoes because it bothers me but he keeps wearing the stained and torn one because "it still can be worn".

load more
User Profile: heatlightning
heatlightning July 31st, 2022

As a woman yes as long as his job is successful and he makes a living he’s just as well off as a doctor lawyer etc if that’s what you’re comparing him to. If he says he works freelance but never actually does any work that’s different but if he’s supporting himself why not? It sounds like he has the body to show for it and is serious about what he does. Also he could get contracts or a job working at a gym should he want super stable permanent employment and is certified. There’s no reason to be ashamed of his job I think it’s just a culture shock kind of thing